| Get surf report

jordy-smith1-1200-th

Mon, 10 June 2019

Who will be in? Spike rolls out the selection road map to the Tokyo Olympics in 2020, and the ISA World Surfing Games 2019 and 2020 are a critical part of the puzzle.


bianca-buitendag-masurel

BIANCA CAN: Don't discount Bianca Buitendag as a contender at the WSG. Photo WSL / Masurel


Getting into the Olympics is a big deal. Its also a tough ask, and according to the requirements to make the 2020 Games in Tokyo, the toughest ask in history. Consider the qualification time for the men's 100 metres, for instance, which is 10.05 seconds for 2029. In 2016, it was 10.16 seconds. In 2012, it was 10.18. In 2008, it was 10.21. In 2000, it was 10,27 and so on, back in time.

South African sprint sensation Akani Simbane will qualify. He ran a 9.95 at the IAAF Diamond League in Shanghai three weeks ago. But he also qualifies by dint of his ranking, the second and only other selection criteria, because he is 6th in the world on the IAAF list as of 4 June 2019. The IAAF Council announced its approval of the qualification system and entry standards for the 2020 Olympic Games in Tokyo at its meeting in Doha in March.

The qualification standard for surfing was not mentioned. That standard has been for the ISA and IOC and WSL to thrash out. Unlike track and field athletics, surfing relies on rankings, since you can't quantify it in terms of speed, distance or height. Or can you? What about number of 10 point rides? Ratio of barrels to heats surfed? Highest average heat scores? Mmmm. That could be interesting.

mikey-february-cestari

FREE SURFING NOW: M-Feb is a great ambassador for the Rainbow Nation. Photo WSL / Cestari


Anyway, the ISA just announced the CT surfers who "have been nominated to represent their National Surfing Teams" at the ISA World Surfing Games (WSG) at Miyazaki, Japan from September 7 to 15, a key milestone in the jouney towards Olympic qualification, although a nigh impossible obstacle if you're a non-CT surfer.

According to the Olympic qualification system, the top 10 eligible men and eight women, with a maximum of two per country, at the end of the 2019 WSL CT season, will qualify for Tokyo 2020. This end-of-year ranking will also be used to determine who gets nominated to be members of their national surfing teams at the 2020 WSG (dates and location still to be announced but they have to be moved forward to accommodate the Olympics, which will be held 24 July – 9 August next year).

I got Robin de Kock of Surfing South Africa (SSA) to clarify the selection process for South Africans. He affirmed that there are two rules for CT surfers and their path to Tokyo. The first is that they must be the highest ranking surfer on the CT (solo in our case). The second requirement is that they must surf in the WSG. CT surfers won't need a result at the WSG. They simply have to rock up.

Smith KELL8831_MRP19_Cestari

ACE UP: Jordy Smith is guaranteed an Olympics spot, if he goes to the WSG. Photo WSL / Cestari


Now that accounts for one member out of six for Team SA at the WSG. What about our legions of non-CT surfers? We still have places for two more men and three women. What a pity that Mikey February's debut on the CT was last year and not this year, but more on that later. More's the pity that Bianca Buitendag is no longer on the CT either. But as SA's highest ranked female (35th on the QS) she should crack the nod.

Anyway, speaking of tough asks, the non-CT qualification route is ruthlessly simple. "To be considered for the Olympics, a non-CT surfer will have to make the final of the World Surfing Games, either in 2019 or 2020. That means you must finish 4th or better in the world at the WSG that year," De Kock said. "The good news is that team members will get two chances!"

Right, okay. But how will our team to the WSG this year be selected? De Kock said: "We use a combination of criteria, from QS rankings to internal results (at SA Champs for instance). We are not beholden to any WSL rankings, or ISA rules. It's an internal decision for us to make. The SSA board has a selection committee who make the decision. The team is then put foward to the SSA board for ratification. Once ratified, it goes to SASCOC to approve."

faulkner

UP AND COMING: Joshe Faulkner is Photo WSL / Cestari


"This process takes place every time we select a team for international competition," he said, adding that the board had not yet decided which criteria they would use in this unique year for surfing, but it would encompass many elements. That said, a question many South Africans will be asking is: "Will there be a place for Mikey February in the team for the WSG?" while others might be asking: "Does Mikey February deserve a place in the team for WSG?"

You have to think that someone who was on the elite tour less than a year ago is a candidate if the rules allow it, which apparently they do. Beyond the IOC ruling, as ratified in negotiation with the ISA and WSL, that CT surfers must surf in the WSG, each country is free to select their team using their own criteria. Spare a thought for the Hawaiians, who have always been afforded their own cultural identity on the CT, but now get lumped under the umbrella of their colonisers, the US of A.

But part of the challenge facing SSA is about how the selection is perceived by the beady eyes of the critical masses, and what is deemed fair. It will be a delicate balancing act. Mikey is sitting at 168th on the Qualifying Series, with eight South Africans above him on the ranking: Matt McGilivray (36), Dylan Lightfoot (39), Adin Masencamp (42), Beyrick de Vries (66), Jake Elkington (84), Jordy Maree (107), Slade Prestwich (138) and Koby Oberholzer (159).

jordy-smith-1200

RING FENCED: Jordy is the solo ou on the world tour, and probably for the Olympics. Photo WSL


You'd feel sorry for someone like Lightfoot if he lost out. These guys have worked hard to be where they are. There is of course the "elephant in the room", although its probably more of a dassie (the closest relative to the elephent) due to protacted and open debate for years - transformation. Like it or not, it is a requirement that any sports team from South Africa is representative.

Fortunately for SSA, there are plenty of talented black youngsters in SA surfing, including Mikey, Tanika Hofman, and Jose Faulkner (just behind February on the QS at #170) to name a few. If his CT experience and his skin colour pushes February up the rankings in the eyes of the SSA, can we honestly complain about that?

The devil you do, the devil you don't. Angry posts will spew forth upon the arbiter of all that is good and bad in the world: social media. It will be rotten luck for some, and an historical moment for others. Let us hope that the SSA chooses wisely. It will be a catch 22, or will it?


CT SURFERS NOMINATED FOR WSG INCLUSION
Australia
Men: Ryan Callinan, Julian Wilson, Owen Wright
Women: Stephanie Gilmore, Sally Fitzgibbons, Nikki Van Dijk
 
Brazil
Men: Italo Ferreira, Filipe Toledo, Gabriel Medina
Women: Tatiana Weston-Webb, Silvana Lima
 
Costa Rica
Women: Brisa Hennessy
 
France
Men: Jeremy Flores, Michel Bourez, Joan Duru
Women: Johanne Defay
 
Italy
Men: Leonardo Fioravanti
 
Japan
Men: Kanoa Igarashi
 
New Zealand
Men: Ricardo Christie
Women: Paige Hareb
 
South Africa
Men: Jordy Smith
 
USA
Men: John John Florence, Kolohe Andino, Connor Coffin
Women: Caroline Marks, Carissa Moore, Courtney Conlogue

HAWAII
Nooit

Add comment

Please don't say anything you would not say to a real person, and please use your real name.


Security code
Refresh

Joomla SEF URLs by Artio

Wavescape on Twitter

Wavescape
Tue Jun 18 10:09:55 +0000 2019

There is already a lot at stake in professional sport, but when the stakes are raised, people start raising their v… https://t.co/uIqq6ivNsA
Wavescape
Fri Jun 14 08:35:51 +0000 2019

The rise of the kneelo was further boosted by a bumper turnout at the Kneelo Gathering 2019, which was held in a qu… https://t.co/cwI5BB8FAE
Wavescape
Thu Jun 13 11:07:23 +0000 2019

KZN South Coast -- The SSW buster in full force Thursday and the coast is smashed sideways by neargale gusts. There… https://t.co/U65c9E3uqw
Wavescape
Thu Jun 13 11:07:21 +0000 2019

Wild Coast -- A stiff SW buster still klaps the Wild Coast early Thursday but eases all day, going light SE by even… https://t.co/RLPar6FTfZ
Wavescape
Thu Jun 13 10:45:57 +0000 2019

Eastern Cape East -- Thursday fires in the west towards PE side, but Slumtown side could puff sideshore south today… https://t.co/hOlvrudZ8P
Wavescape
Thu Jun 13 10:38:02 +0000 2019

Eastern Cape West -- Bruuu! Thursday fires 6' in clean offshore west winds light and smooth. The swell direction ve… https://t.co/4nJU9nt0Yx
Follow Wavescape on Twitter

Wavescape friends and partners Isiqalo Foundation DIFF CSIR Isiqalo Foundation Surfing  South Africa Save Our Seas Shark Centre Isiqalo Foundation Red Bull Media House DIFF National Sea Rescue Institute Shark Spotters ASP Africa